Free to read Currents

Dopamine, Detoxed

Can a weekend without screens, sugar or music reset a brain chemical? Ask instead what the brochure is selling.

The Mind · · 5 min read

The weekend is in Coorg, and it costs about what a weekend in Coorg costs, and for the money one gets a room with no television, meals with no sugar, a box at reception for the phone, and a printed card asking guests not to speak to one another before four. The brochure calls it a dopamine detox. By Sunday evening, it promises, the brain will have reset, and the ordinary pleasures, a mango, a walk, a face, will have their colour back.

The idea is seven years old and has done well. In 2019 a psychologist in San Francisco published a guide to what he called dopamine fasting, which was a sensible programme of cutting back, for set hours, on six habits he thought his clients were ruled by: the phone, the junk food, the gaming, the shopping, the pornography, and the rest. It was ordinary behavioural therapy, the kind that treats a habit by removing its cues, and he said so. Then a newspaper found a handful of young men in the Bay Area who had taken it further and were wandering from room to room refusing eye contact, and the headline wrote itself, and the practice has been a weekend package ever since.

What the package has that the original did not is the word dopamine, and the word is doing all the work.

Dopamine

A chemical messenger made in a few small clusters of cells deep in the brain and sent to many places. In the circuits the fast is concerned with, it signals the difference between what was expected and what arrived: a surprise, in either direction, and a nudge to pay attention and do it again, or not. Pleasure is a different matter. It cannot be stored up, used up, or fasted from. A brain without it does not feel the world more keenly. It cannot move.

The popular picture of dopamine is of a reservoir. Every screen and sweet draws some off, the level drops, the ordinary pleasures no longer register, and a weekend of nothing lets the tank refill. The picture is wrong in every part. Dopamine is released and cleared in fractions of a second, continuously, in response to the world as it comes, and the small store the cells keep is not drained by a phone or topped up by a quiet weekend. A weekend without the phone does nothing to the quantity of dopamine in anyone’s head, and the neuroscientists asked about the fast have said so, in words ranging from unfounded to nonsense.

What the fast does do is real, and it is smaller, and it is older.

Taking the phone away for two days removes the cues. The brain stops being asked, forty times an hour, to check whether something has arrived. That is a relief, and the relief is what the guests feel on Sunday, and it is the same relief a person feels after a week at a relative’s house with poor signal. It is not a reset. It is a rest, and it ends when the box at reception is opened on the way to the car.

The second thing the weekend does is make a person bored, and boredom turns out to be where the pleasure was hiding. A mango eaten after two days of plain food is the same mango, and the same tongue, and the same dopamine, released on the same principle: this was better than expected. The brain has refilled nothing; the comparison has changed, and lowering the expectation improves the mango. The brochure has rediscovered the oldest fact about appetite, which every religion in the country built a fast around, and has dressed it in the vocabulary of the lab.

Why, then, does the idea survive its correction? It has been corrected in print every year since it appeared, by the man who invented it among others, and the weekends are fuller than ever.

Because the word dopamine does something the word habit cannot. It locates the trouble in the chemistry, where it is nobody’s fault, and promises a fix that is chemical, which is to say quick, which is to say a weekend. A habit is a thing a person does, and the remedy for a habit is to do differently, every day, for a long time, which is dull and has no brochure. A dopamine level is a thing that happens to a person, and can be put right by a treatment, and a treatment can be bought. The guests in Coorg are paying for a story in which the difficulty belongs to nobody, and least of all to them.

The weekend is a good idea. Two days without the phone is a good idea. The guests will sleep better and come home a little quieter and most of them will be back on the phone by Monday noon, because the phone will be where they left it and the cues will be where they left them and the weekend did nothing to either.

On Sunday at four the box at reception is opened, and the phones go back into the hands that handed them over, and nothing in the hands has changed.

Sources

  • Sepah, C. (2019). “The definitive guide to dopamine fasting 2.0: the hot Silicon Valley trend.” LinkedIn, August 2019.
  • Bowles, N. (2019). “How to feel nothing now, in order to feel more later.” The New York Times, 7 November 2019.
  • Grinspoon, P. (2020). “Dopamine fasting: misunderstanding science spawns a maladaptive fad.” Harvard Health Blog, 26 February 2020.
  • Schultz, W., Dayan, P. and Montague, P. R. (1997). “A neural substrate of prediction and reward.” Science, 275(5306), 1593 to 1599.

Share this piece

Replies

Nothing here yet.

Replies are for subscribers, signed in.

Sign in

Not a subscriber yet?