A Bag Full of Bags
Forty bags, folded into triangles, in one bag on a nail. Where thrift stops and the psychiatrist's word begins.
The Mind · · 5 min readEvery kitchen in the country keeps a bag full of bags, and the house has long since forgotten who started it.
It hangs on a nail behind the fridge, or it is wedged between the gas cylinder and the wall, and it is always one size too small for what it holds. It began, presumably, as a single bag from a sari shop. It now contains forty bags, give or take, each folded into a triangle by a method that is passed down and never taught, and from it the house draws a liner for the bin, a wrapping for the cook’s lunch, something to carry the coconut shells out, and a spare for the vegetable man, who has stopped bringing his own. Its neighbours in the house are well known. The drawer of rubber bands. The steel tin of buttons cut off shirts that were given away. Ice-cream tubs that have not held ice cream since the year they were bought, and now hold dal. Gift paper, ironed. And in the loft, the cardboard box the television came in, kept against the day the family moves and needs to carry a television, which has not happened in eleven years and is not, on any current plan, going to.
The children laugh at all of this. Somewhere around the age of thirty they open a drawer in their own flat and find it full of rubber bands.
Psychiatry has had a formal word for the extreme end of this since 2013, when the American manual gave hoarding a diagnosis of its own instead of filing it as a symptom of something else. It is not rare. A review of eleven studies covering more than fifty thousand people put it at about two and a half in every hundred adults, in the wealthier countries where it has been counted. It usually begins in the teens and gets worse with the years, the clutter most of all. In a study of older adults with the condition, the median person remembered the first signs from somewhere between ten and twenty.
The test has no interest in how many objects there are. It begins with three questions. Does the person find it persistently hard to part with possessions, whatever they are worth? Does throwing them away cause real distress, because of a felt need to keep them? And then the question that does the work: have the possessions piled up until they congest the rooms of the house and stop those rooms being used for what they are for? A bed that cannot be slept in. A kitchen too full to cook in. A sofa that holds newspapers from 2019 and has not held a person since. The manual even closes the loophole that every family will recognise: if the rooms are clear only because a daughter or a cleaner keeps clearing them, it still counts. Only after all that does it ask whether any of this causes real distress, or gets in the way of a life.
By that test the bag of bags is the opposite of the illness. It has a fixed address. Everyone in the house knows where it is. Things go into it and, more to the point, they come out of it again, every day, for a purpose. It is an inventory, run by someone who knows exactly what is in it. What the clinicians are describing is what happens when that system fails: when the bags are no longer in one bag, when the keeping has spread past the kitchen into the corridor and the spare room, and when every attempt by somebody else to throw any of it out produces a quarrel out of all proportion to a stack of old receipts.
And the bag holds something besides bags. The people who started it grew up in a country of waiting lists. A telephone line took years. A scooter took years. Kerosene came in a queue. Nothing was thrown away because nothing could be counted on to come back, and a house that kept things was a house that could manage. The habit was not a symptom. It was competence, learned at a particular time, and it has outlived the conditions that taught it, as competence often does.
The conditions have since doubled back. In 2021 the government raised the minimum thickness of plastic carry bags, and from the last day of 2022 anything thinner than 120 microns was banned. The thin, crackling bags that fill the bag of bags are now banned; in Karnataka, carry bags of any thickness have been since 2016. The old woman in the kitchen, folding her triangles, is now the custodian of a discontinued currency, and every time the vegetable man asks for a bag, she is proved right.
What settles it, for a particular house, is the rooms. The number of things is beside the point, and so is their usefulness, which is a matter of opinion and tends to be the children’s. A house can hold one bag full of bags for ever. What the clinician wants to know is only whether it can still hold the people.
Sources
- American Psychiatric Association, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fifth edition (American Psychiatric Association, 2013): hoarding disorder.
- Postlethwaite, A., Kellett, S. and Mataix-Cols, D. (2019). “Prevalence of hoarding disorder: a systematic review and meta-analysis.” Journal of Affective Disorders, 256, 309 to 316.
- Dozier, M. E., Porter, B. and Ayers, C. R. (2016). “Age of onset and progression of hoarding symptoms in older adults with hoarding disorder.” Aging and Mental Health, 20(7), 736 to 742.
- Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, Plastic Waste Management (Amendment) Rules, 2021, notified 12 August 2021.
- Government of Karnataka, Department of Forest, Ecology and Environment, notification banning plastic carry bags, 11 March 2016.
The letter
One letter with each new piece. Nothing else, and your address goes nowhere.
We send one confirmation email. You are not on the list until you click it.




Replies
Nothing here yet.
Replies are for subscribers, signed in.
Sign inNot a subscriber yet?